Is Afya Sacco on verge of collapse?

 



Lwanga Mbeche, the Chief Executive Officer of Afya Sacco, finds himself in a challenging situation as the once-thriving sacco is now perceived as a mere shadow of its former self. Reports of mismanagement have surfaced, leading to a withdrawal of membership as concerns grow that the sacco is on the brink of collapse.

  For the past six months, the sacco has been experiencing a wave of panic withdrawals from members, who cite corruption, mismanagement, and financial misconduct by the officials as their reasons. The dismissal of General Manager – Human Resources, Robert Kimanzi Muinde, has placed the management in a difficult position, especially since the Employment and Labor Relations Court has ruled that his termination was unjust. The court has mandated the sacco to compensate him for the unfair termination of his contract, amounting to Ksh. 5,114,725.00, along with Ksh. 635,459.00 for the commutation of accrued leave days. The current concern is that the sacco's financial stability is in jeopardy, and the obligation to pay the total award of Ksh. 5.8 million could exacerbate the financial turmoil facing the organization.

Judgment: Robert Kimanzi Muinde vs. Afya Co-operative Savings and Credit Society Ltd

Background

This case revolves around the termination of Robert Kimanzi Muinde's employment with Afya Co-operative Savings and Credit Society Ltd. The Claimant, Mr. Muinde, challenges the decision of the Respondent to terminate his contract, alleging it was done unlawfully under the guise of early retirement.

Employment History
  1. Initial Engagement and Promotions:
    Mr. Muinde began his employment with the Respondent on April 2, 1984. Over the years, he rose through the ranks, eventually being appointed as General Manager – Human Resources and Administration effective January 2, 2024.

  2. Service and Performance:
    Throughout his tenure, Mr. Muinde asserts he served diligently, receiving promotions, certificates of recognition, and commendations for his exemplary performance.


Disciplinary Proceedings and Termination
  1. Interdiction and Accusations:
    On August 12, 2024, the Respondent issued Mr. Muinde with a letter of interdiction and intention of summary dismissal. The accusations included failing to foresee a crisis from a human resource perspective and economic sabotage.

  2. Response and Hearing:
    Mr. Muinde was given only one day to respond to these accusations and was barred from accessing the workplace. He submitted his response and attended a disciplinary hearing on August 29, 2024.

  3. Lack of Due Process:
    The Claimant argues that the Respondent failed to provide him with a required report associated with his interdiction and did not substantiate the allegations during the disciplinary process.

  4. Summary Dismissal:
    Despite these proceedings, Mr. Muinde received a letter of summary dismissal on the grounds of early retirement, which he contested as unlawful.


Issues of Retirement
  1. Retirement Policy:
    The Respondent's Management Staff Terms and Conditions of Service Manual allows voluntary retirement at 50 and sets the mandatory retirement age at 60. Mr. Muinde, at 59, argues he was prematurely forced into early retirement.

  2. Appeal Ignored:
    Mr. Muinde appealed against the decision, requesting to continue service until reaching the mandatory retirement age, but his appeal was ignored.


Legal Claims

Mr. Muinde seeks the following remedies:

  • Declarations that his service was unlawfully terminated and his rights were violated.

  • Monetary Compensation including:

    • Commutation of 41 accumulated leave days into cash.

    • Payment of unlawfully withheld salary.

    • Salary in lieu of notice.

    • Salary covering the term until the mandatory retirement age.

    • Compensation for unfair termination equivalent to 12 months’ salary.

  • Certificate of Service.

  • Interest on the claimed amounts.

  • Costs of the suit.

Testimonies and Evidence

During the trial, Mr. Muinde adopted his witness statement and presented supporting documents as evidence. He reiterated that his termination was based on early retirement, which he did not opt for. The Claimant emphasized the retirement policy stipulations and his forced retirement before reaching 60.

Cross-Examination

In cross-examination, Mr. Muinde confirmed his date of birth as August 15, 1965, suggesting his retirement was due in August 2025. He acknowledged various departmental transfers and trainings but admitted he lacked specialized training in Human Resource management.


This judgment aims to determine whether Mr. Muinde's termination was indeed unlawful and if he is entitled to the claims he seeks against Afya Co-operative Savings and Credit Society Ltd.


Court Ruling Summary: ELRC Cause No E1086 of 2024

Findings and Orders

After careful evaluation of the pleadings, evidence, and submissions presented by both parties, the court arrived at the following determinations and issued the corresponding orders:

Declaration of Unlawful Termination
  • The court finds and declares that the Respondent improperly and unlawfully terminated the Claimant’s contract of service.

Compensation for Unfair Termination
  • The court awards the Claimant a sum of Ksh. 5,114,725.00 as compensation for the unfair termination of his contract of service.

Accrued Leave Days
  • The court awards the Claimant an additional sum of Ksh. 635,459.00 for the commutation of accrued leave days.

Denied Claims
  • The court declines the prayers for:

    • Salary for the remainder of the Claimant’s term.

    • Salary shortfalls for August and September 2024.

    • Pay in lieu of notice for terminating the Claimant’s contract of service.

Certificate of Service
  • The court orders the Respondent to issue a corrected version of the Claimant’s Certificate of Service.

Interest and Costs
  • The court awards the Claimant interest on the awarded amounts at court rates from the date of this decision.

  • The court awards the Claimant the costs of the case.

Statutory Deductions
  • The awarded amount to the Claimant is subject to any statutory deductions that were applicable at the time the contract between the parties was terminated.


Dated, signed, and delivered on the 29th day of October, 2026
B. O. M. MANANI
JUDGE

Post a Comment

0 Comments