Employees at Nicola Limited's hotel in Malindi, known as Diamonds Malindi, have mustered the courage to anonymously express their grievances regarding their prolonged suffering in silence.
A notable case involves a former employee, Vincent Kipkirui Langat, who was unjustly terminated from his position as the Food & Beverage Service Manager and subsequently sued the hotel.
Judgment Summary: ELRC Cause No. E011 of 2025
A. Introduction
The case in question involves Vincent Kipkirui Langat (the Claimant), a hospitality professional who was employed as the Food & Beverage Service Manager at Nicola Limited's hotel in Malindi, known as Diamonds Malindi. His employment was terminated within four months, and the Claimant argues that the dismissal was unfair, as the alleged poor performance was not objectively measured. The Respondent, Nicola Limited, contends that the dismissal was due to the Claimant's failure to meet expected performance standards.
B. The Claimant's Case
Employment Details: The Claimant was employed on a one-year renewable contract starting from 1st October 2024, with a gross monthly salary of Kshs. 280,000.
Termination: On 27th January 2025, the Claimant's employment was terminated on grounds of alleged non-performance. He argues that this allegation was vague, with no clear standards or opportunity for him to improve.
Claims for Relief: The Claimant seeks a declaration that his termination was unlawful and unfair, along with compensation equivalent to twelve months' salary (Kshs. 3,360,000), interest, and costs of the suit.
Evidence Presented: During the hearing, the Claimant shared that initial concerns raised by his managers were addressed promptly. However, he was later issued a notice to show cause and a subsequent disciplinary hearing, after which his termination was finalized. He asserts his performance was never formally assessed.
C. The Respondent's Case
Contractual Terms: The Respondent acknowledges the employment and the terms but emphasizes that the first six months were probationary, allowing for contract termination on grounds of non-performance or unsuitability.
Performance Issues: The Respondent claims the Claimant exhibited unprofessional behavior, including arrogance and refusal to obey orders. They assert that despite feedback and guidance, his performance did not meet the required standards.
Termination Procedure: The Respondent followed the procedure outlined in the Employment Act, issuing a notice to show cause, conducting a disciplinary hearing, and ultimately terminating the Claimant's employment. They argue that the Claimant did not utilize the internal grievance process available to him.
Conclusion: The Respondent requests the suit be dismissed with costs, claiming that the termination was justified and all terminal dues were settled.
Summary
The core issue in this case is whether the termination of the Claimant's employment was conducted fairly and in accordance with employment law. The Claimant contends that the process was a mere formality to justify a premeditated decision, while the Respondent maintains that the termination was justified due to poor performance and conduct. The court's decision will hinge on evaluating the fairness of the assessment and disciplinary process followed by the Respondent.
Judgment Summary: Employment Termination Case
Background
The Claimant's employment was found to be unfairly terminated, leading to a legal dispute resolved under the Employment Act. The Claimant sought a declaration of unfair termination and appropriate compensation.
Legal Provisions
Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act
This section empowers the Court to award an employee compensation equivalent to a number of months' wages, not exceeding twelve months, based on the gross monthly wage or salary at the time of termination. The award is discretionary and must consider factors such as:
Circumstances of the termination
Employee's length of service
Employee's reasonable expectation of continued employment
Opportunities for securing comparable employment
Any compensation already paid
Compensation aims to address the wrong, not enrich the employee.
Case Details
Claimant's Position
Maximum Award Sought: The Claimant sought the maximum compensation of twelve months' gross salary.
Employment Duration: Less than four months with the Respondent.
Contract Terms: Employed on a one-year fixed-term contract.
Court's Findings
Procedural Compliance: The Respondent complied with section 41 procedural requirements; the unfairness was substantive.
Termination Impact: Termination occurred early in the employment, labeling the Claimant as incompetent. This may harm future employment opportunities.
Employment Expectations: The Claimant reasonably expected to serve eight more months and potentially have the contract renewed.
Court's Decision
Compensation Award
Award Amount: Two months' gross salary, totaling Kshs. 560,000.
Rationale: The award balances the early termination's impact on the Claimant's career and the actual service duration.
Interest and Costs
Interest: The award will accrue interest at court rates from the judgment date until full payment.
Costs: The Claimant, having substantially succeeded, is awarded the costs of the suit.
Orders
Unfair Termination Declaration: The termination was substantively unfair.
Compensation: The Respondent must pay Kshs. 560,000 as compensation.
Interest: Applicable court rates until complete payment.
Costs: The Respondent bears the suit's costs.
Judgment Date
The judgment was dated, signed, and delivered virtually at Malindi on the 27th day of October, 2026, by Judge Ocharo Kebira.


0 Comments