All is not well at Al Hunain Motors Limited following the dismissal of their appeal by a High Court judge in an accident compensation case involving Jimmy Mule Mutunga, which has resulted in an order for the company to compensate the accident victim.
The driver involved in the incident has already been terminated and is now enduring a difficult life, having been dismissed without any compensation or payment of his terminal benefits. The management's practice of terminating drivers and other employees without compensation has become widespread, with numerous such cases still pending in court. Al Hussain Motors Limited has a notorious reputation for mistreatment of staff, offering inadequate salaries, terminating employees without compensation, and providing a poor working environment. The company is also known to engage in various illegal activities, including tax evasion, unlawful repossession, breach of contract, disputes over vehicle sales and refund claims, traffic accident liability claims, and disputes regarding vehicle import duties with the KRA, among others. Management operates the company through coercion, intimidation, heavy-handedness, and threats. There have been allegations against a senior manager who is reportedly known for soliciting sexual favors from married employees, threatening victimization if they refuse. This manager has a troubling preference for married women and has been known to undermine female staff.
High Court of Kenya: Civil Appeal No. E283 of 2025
Introduction
This document pertains to a civil appeal filed in the High Court of Kenya at Nairobi, specifically within the Milimani Commercial Courts. The appeal, designated as Civil Appeal No. E283 of 2025, involves the appellants, Al Hussain Motors Limited and Frankline Mucheri Nyaga, versus the respondent, Jimmy Mule Mutunga.
Origin of Appeal: The appeal arises from a judgment and decree delivered by Hon. H. A. Okello, Resident Magistrate, on 28th February 2025, in the case of Jimmy Mule Mutunga v Al Hussain Motors Limited & Another (Milimani CMCC No. E4872 of 2023). The trial court ruled in favor of the respondent, Jimmy Mule Mutunga, against the appellants.
Trial Court's Findings: The trial court held the appellants wholly responsible for a road traffic accident that occurred on 13th July 2023. It awarded the respondent general damages amounting to Kshs. 800,000, future medical expenses of Kshs. 100,000, and special damages of Kshs. 10,790, alongside costs and interest.
Grounds for Appeal: The appellants, dissatisfied with the assessment of general damages, filed a Memorandum of Appeal on 11th March 2025. They seek to have the award of general damages set aside, reduced, or varied. The seven grounds raised in the Memorandum principally challenge the trial court's discretion in assessing general damages, arguing that the award was excessively high and that the magistrate did not adequately apply the principles governing damage assessment or consider comparable awards and the appellants' submissions.
Background
Initiation of Proceedings: The respondent initiated proceedings against the appellants through a plaint dated 10th November 2023, claiming compensation for injuries allegedly sustained in a road traffic accident on Argwings Kodhek Road, near Nairobi Hospital, on 13th July 2023.
Respondent's Allegations: The respondent claimed he was lawfully walking along the said road when a vehicle, registration number KDJ 741L, owned by the 1st appellant and driven by the 2nd appellant, was negligently operated, causing it to lose control and knock him down, resulting in bodily injuries.
Injuries Detailed:
Blunt injuries to the right lower limb, with loss of friction and tenderness.
A closed bimalleolar fracture of the right ankle joint.
Appellants' Defense: The appellants filed a Statement of Defence on 4th January 2024, denying liability and attributing the accident to the respondent's negligence.
Respondent's Testimony: During the hearing, the respondent testified (as PW1) and adopted his witness statement from 10th November 2023. He described sustaining injuries to his right ankle, undergoing treatment with metal implants, and being unable to resume his regular work. He also stated the need for further medical treatment.
Cross-Examination Admissions: Under cross-examination, the respondent admitted not having photographic evidence of the accident scene, documentary proof of his earnings, or a disability assessment report. Nonetheless, he maintained he was walking beside the road when the vehicle lost control and hit him.
Police Testimony: PW2, Police Constable Andrew Babu, presented a police abstract related to the accident. He admitted he was not the investigating officer, had not conducted the accident investigation personally, and did not have the police investigation file.
Appellants' Evidence: The appellants did not present any witnesses to support their defense. The trial court concluded that the respondent had established liability against the appellants on a balance of probabilities, assigning 100% liability to them.
Quantum of Damages: The magistrate considered a medical report by Dr. Titus Ndeti Nzina, discharge summaries from Kenyatta National Hospital, and the submissions from both parties. The court awarded Kshs. 800,000 for general damages, Kshs. 100,000 for future medical expenses, and Kshs. 10,790 for special damages.
This summary outlines the key aspects of the appeal, providing a comprehensive understanding of the case background, the trial court's findings, and the grounds for the appellants' appeal.
Court Judgment Summary
Case Overview
In the recent judgment, the court evaluated the appeal presented in relation to the trial court's decision in Milimani CMCC No. E4872 of 2023. The appeal was assessed based on the Memorandum of Appeal, the Record of Appeal, the parties' submissions, and the applicable law.
Orders Issued
After thorough consideration, the court found the appeal to be merited in part and issued the following orders:
Partial Allowance of Appeal: The appeal is partially allowed, reflecting the court's decision to amend certain aspects of the trial court's original judgment.
Adjustment of General Damages:
The original award of Kshs. 800,000 in general damages has been set aside.
It is replaced with a new award of Kshs. 500,000.
Liability:
The trial court's finding of 100% liability against the Appellants is upheld.
Special Damages and Future Medical Expenses:
The awards of Kshs. 100,000 for future medical expenses and Kshs. 10,790 for special damages are upheld.
Total Principal Award:
The total principal amount payable to the Respondent is Kshs. 610,790, itemized as follows:
General Damages: Kshs. 500,000
Special Damages: Kshs. 10,790
Future Medical Expenses: Kshs. 100,000
Total Award: Kshs. 610,790
Costs and Interest:
The trial court's orders on costs and interest remain unchanged. Interest will apply to the respective heads of damages as per the trial court's decree.
Costs of the Appeal:
As the appeal was only partially successful, and in accordance with Section 27(1) of the Civil Procedure Act, each party will bear its own costs of the appeal.
Conclusion
The judgment was dated, signed, and delivered in Nairobi on the 29th day of October, 2026, by Honorable L. P. Kassan, Judge.
Other notable legal cases and accusations involving the dealership include:
1. Unlawful Repossession and Breach of Contract
·
The Case: Al-Husnain Motors Limited & another v Kiprono (2025).
[1]
·
The Accusation: The buyer, Isaac Kipkemoi Kiprono, accused the dealership
of unlawfully repossessing his motor vehicle without prior notice of default
and failing to hand over the necessary transfer documents and logbook. [1]
·
Outcome: The High Court at Iten dismissed the dealership's appeal.
The court upheld the judgment declaring the repossession illegal and ordered
the dealer to surrender the logbook and transfer forms to the buyer. [1]
2. Vehicle Sale Dispute and Refund Claim
·
The Case: Al-Husnain Motors Ltd v Joshua Matagaro Michira
(2018/2021/2026).
·
The Accusation: The respondent sued the dealership for a breach of contract
regarding a vehicle purchase, demanding a permanent injunction or a full refund
of Ksh. 2,381,000.
·
Outcome: The dealership's subsequent appeals, including one at the
Court of Appeal in Kisumu, were dismissed. [1, 2]
3. Traffic Accident Liability Claims
·
The Case: Al-Husnain Motors Limited v David Eshiunwa Saya (2023).
[1]
·
The Dispute: The dealership was sued following a traffic accident
involving a vehicle registered under its name. The company attempted to vacate
an ex-parte judgment, claiming it had already sold the vehicle to a
third party before the accident occurred and was unaware of the court
proceedings. [1]
·
Outcome: The High Court rejected the company's defence, citing that
public traffic records still designated the dealership as the legal owner. [1]
4. Vehicle Import Duty Dispute with the KRA
·
The Case: Car Importers Association of Kenya & Al-Husnain
Motors Ltd v Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA).
·
The Dispute: In this instance, the dealership was the accuser rather
than the accused. They sued the KRA for unlawfully detaining two imported
Toyota Land Cruiser V8 units and demanding inflated tax duties based on an
unprocedural Current Retail Selling Price (CRSP) matrix.
·
Outcome: The High Court ruled in favor of the car importers,
ordering the KRA to immediately release the detained vehicles. [1]

0 Comments