Blue Omnibus Ltd MD Ajul Shah caught pants down, staff mistreatment and claims Atwoli protecting him



Employees at Blue Omnibus Ltd, a company based in Mombasa, have raised concerns about an allegedly toxic workplace and unfair labour practices.

The company specializes in medical equipment and supplies. However, employees allege that they face inhumane working conditions, low pay, excessive working hours without overtime compensation, and dismissal for trivial reasons without compensation. They accuse Managing Director Ajul Shah of allowing managers to mistreat staff. One manager is alleged to have sexually harassed female employees and demanded sexual favours, with those who refused reportedly facing victimization and dismissal. Employees also accuse Shah of mismanaging the company and evading taxes. They say deductions for the Social Health Authority (SHA), the Housing Levy, the National Social Security Fund (NSSF), and PAYE are taken from their salaries but not remitted. They are calling on the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) to investigate the allegations of tax evasion. Shah is reportedly known for boasting that he is untouchable because Central Organization of Trade Unions (COTU) Secretary-General Francis Atwoli is his personal friend and receives a monthly payment for protection. Employees allege that Shah claims this connection ensures labour officials cannot take action against him, and that the protection allows him to mistreat staff. Recently, Shah suffered a setback when the Employment and Labour Relations Court dismissed his appeal against former employee Kaphenji John Muthami. Shah had sought to have the court overturn a judgment that found Muthami’s termination of employment to be unfair.

Judgment Summary: Blue Omnibus Limited vs. Kaphenji John Muthami

Background

In the Employment and Labour Relations Court at Mombasa, Blue Omnibus Limited (the Appellant) filed an appeal against the judgment delivered by the Magistrate’s Court, presided over by Honourable Lucy K. Sindani. The judgment in question awarded Kaphenji John Muthami (the Respondent) a sum of Kshs. 152,400.00 plus costs and interest, following a finding of unfair termination of employment.


Grounds for Appeal

The Appellant presented several grounds for the appeal, including:

  1. Error in Law and Fact: The Trial Magistrate allegedly erred by awarding the Respondent damages without sufficient evidence of continuous regular employment.

  2. Misinterpretation of Employment Terms: It was argued that the Respondent was engaged under fixed-term contracts and as a casual employee, which was not adequately considered.

  3. Unfair Termination Ruling: The Appellant claimed there was no evidence to support the finding of unfair termination, including a failure to acknowledge an alleged voluntary separation by the Respondent.

  4. Burden of Proof: The Appellant contended that the burden of proof was improperly shifted to them, contrary to Section 47(5) of the Employment Act.

  5. Compensation and Leave Pay: The Appellant argued that the award of compensation and leave pay was excessive, lacked justification, and improperly shifted the burden of proof.

Court's Analysis and Findings

  1. Nature of Employment: The court considered the evidence, including employment contracts and payment records. It concluded that the Appellant did not sufficiently demonstrate intermittent or casual employment to counter the claim of regular employment.

  2. Unfair Termination: The court upheld the finding of unfair termination, noting that the Appellant failed to justify the grounds for termination and did not adhere to procedural requirements under Sections 41, 43, and 45 of the Employment Act.

  3. Voluntary Termination: The court reviewed the Respondent’s letter allegedly acknowledging voluntary termination. However, it found discrepancies in the timing and circumstances of the Appellant’s termination notice.

  4. Compensation: The award of ten months' salary as compensation was deemed appropriate, given the Respondent’s length of service and lack of a disciplinary hearing. The court found no misuse of judicial discretion warranting interference with the compensation awarded.

  5. Leave Pay: The Appellant’s failure to provide evidence of leave taken or paid justified the award for leave pay. The court upheld the Magistrate’s decision to award 18 months of leave pay.

  6. Overall Evidence Consideration: The court found that the Trial Magistrate adequately considered the entirety of the evidence, including employment records and the Appellant's submissions.

The appeal by Blue Omnibus Limited was dismissed, with the court upholding the original judgment by Honourable Lucy K. Sindani. The Appellant was ordered to bear the costs of the appeal, affirming the decision of unfair termination and the associated awards to the Respondent.



Examination of Evidence

The Court reviewed the Respondent’s handwritten letter dated 13th July 2021, where she allegedly acknowledged voluntarily terminating her employment. However, a prior letter from the Appellant dated 17th March 2021 declared her no longer employed, with another letter on 30th March 2021 regarding termination and NSSF dues. Crucially, testimony from RW1 indicated the Respondent’s inability to read or write, leading the Court to agree with the learned Magistrate that the letter could not conclusively prove voluntary resignation.


Burden of Proof Under the Employment Act

Under Section 47(5) of the Employment Act, the employee must initially prove unfair termination, while the employer must justify the termination grounds. The Court concluded that the Respondent demonstrated her separation was due to the Appellant’s actions. The Appellant failed to prove abscondment or comply with procedural and substantive requirements under Sections 41, 43, and 45 of the Employment Act. Thus, the finding of unfair termination was upheld.


Remedies and Compensation

The Court upheld the award of Kshs. 12,480/= in lieu of notice under Section 35(1)(c) of the Employment Act. Regarding compensation, the learned Magistrate awarded Kshs. 124,800/=, equivalent to ten months' salary, considering the Respondent’s length of service and termination circumstances. The Court found no improper exercise of discretion in this award.


Leave Pay

Testimony from RW1 confirmed the Respondent had not taken leave, and no evidence of leave encashment was provided. The Appellant's documents did not prove leave was taken or paid, leading the Court to uphold the award of Kshs. 15,120/= for eighteen months of unpaid leave.


Consideration of Evidence

The Appellant argued the learned Magistrate failed to fully consider the evidence. However, the judgment showed thorough consideration of contracts, attendance records, correspondence, abscondment allegations, and NSSF contributions. Part of the Appellant's limitation argument was upheld, dismissing the service pay claim. The Court found no misapprehension of evidence warranting interference with the judgment.


Conclusion

The Appeal was found to lack merit and was dismissed with costs awarded to the Respondent. The judgment and decree by Hon. L. K. Sindani from Mombasa MCELRC No. E484 of 2023 were upheld.

Order Issued:
Dated at Mombasa this 5th day of November 2026
Delivered virtually this 5th day of November 2026
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
Presiding Judge - ELRC Mombasa

Post a Comment

0 Comments