Gold Crown Foods (EPZ) Limited has suffered a major legal defeat and reputational setback after the Employment and Labour Relations Court in Mombasa ordered it to compensate former manager Mr. Moses Opiyo in Employment and Labour Relations Cause No. E101 of 2025. In a judgment delivered by Justice K. Ocharo on October 27, 2026, the court found that Opiyo’s termination was unfair.According to a sworn affidavit, Moses Opiyo worked as the company’s Human Resource Manager for nearly ten years, from March 1, 2013, until October 18, 2022, when management summarily dismissed him for alleged gross misconduct.
Judgment Summary
Introduction
In the Employment and Labour Relations Court at Mombasa, under Employment and Labour Relations Cause E101 of 2025, this case involves Mr. Moses Opiyo (the Claimant) and Gold Crown Foods (EPZ) Limited (the Respondent). The judgment was delivered by Justice K. Ocharo on October 27, 2026.
Background
The claimant, Moses Opiyo, filed a lawsuit against his former employer, Gold Crown Foods (EPZ) Limited, alleging unlawful termination of his employment. The claimant sought various remedies including compensation for unfair dismissal, unpaid dues, and other related benefits.
Claimant’s Position
Moses Opiyo argued that his termination was without just cause and contrary to the principles of natural justice. He claimed that he was not given a fair hearing before his dismissal and that the reasons provided for his termination were unfounded. Opiyo sought:
Reinstatement to his former position or
Compensation equivalent to 12 months' salary for unfair dismissal
Payment of any outstanding salary and benefits
Issuance of a certificate of service
Respondent’s Position
Gold Crown Foods (EPZ) Limited contended that the termination was justified and conducted in accordance with the employment contract and the company’s internal regulations. The respondent cited instances of misconduct and poor performance as reasons for the dismissal. They argued that:
The claimant was given multiple warnings
Due process was followed in the termination procedure
The claimant’s performance was below the required standard
Case Summary: Unfair Dismissal Judgment
Judgment Overview
In this case, the court has ruled in favor of the Claimant against the Respondent, following an assessment of the Claimant's dismissal circumstances. The judgment is structured as follows:
Declaration of Unfair Dismissal
Procedural and Substantive Unfairness:
A declaration has been issued stating that the Claimant's summary dismissal by the Respondent on October 18, 2022, was both procedurally and substantively unfair.
Procedural and Substantive Unfairness:
A declaration has been issued stating that the Claimant's summary dismissal by the Respondent on October 18, 2022, was both procedurally and substantively unfair.
Compensation and Payments
Compensation for Unfair Termination:
The Respondent is required to compensate the Claimant according to section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act. This compensation amounts to seven months' gross salary, totaling Kshs. 2,445,716.
Salary in Lieu of Notice:
Additionally, the Respondent must pay one month's salary in lieu of notice, which amounts to Kshs. 349,388.
Total Compensation:
The total monetary compensation awarded to the Claimant is Kshs. 2,795,104.
Compensation for Unfair Termination:
The Respondent is required to compensate the Claimant according to section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act. This compensation amounts to seven months' gross salary, totaling Kshs. 2,445,716.
Salary in Lieu of Notice:
Additionally, the Respondent must pay one month's salary in lieu of notice, which amounts to Kshs. 349,388.
Total Compensation:
The total monetary compensation awarded to the Claimant is Kshs. 2,795,104.
Additional Provisions
Statutory Deductions:
The awarded sums are subject to statutory deductions where applicable.
Interest on Awarded Sums:
The compensation amounts will accrue interest at the court's standard rates from the date of this judgment until the full payment is made.
Costs of the Suit:
The Respondent is also ordered to bear the costs associated with this legal suit.
Statutory Deductions:
The awarded sums are subject to statutory deductions where applicable.
Interest on Awarded Sums:
The compensation amounts will accrue interest at the court's standard rates from the date of this judgment until the full payment is made.
Costs of the Suit:
The Respondent is also ordered to bear the costs associated with this legal suit.
Finalization
The judgment, including all orders and compensations, was dated, signed, and delivered at Mombasa on the 27th day of October 2026 by Judge Ocharo Kebira.
Judgment in the Employment and Labour Relations Court at Mombasa
Introduction
The case at hand involves the dismissal of Moses Opiyo, who served as the Human Resource Manager for Gold Crown Foods (EPZ) Limited for nearly a decade. His dismissal was grounded on allegations of gross misconduct, primarily revolving around a conflict of interest involving a business owned by his wife. This judgment seeks to determine whether the dismissal was both procedurally and substantively fair, taking into account various critical factors and evidence presented.
The Claimant’s Case
Background and Claims
Employment History: Moses Opiyo was employed as a Human Resource Manager from 1st March 2013 until his dismissal on 18th October 2022. His termination was contested on the grounds of lacking justifiable cause and being procedurally unfair.
Claims for Relief:
One month’s salary in lieu of notice amounting to Kshs. 349,388.
Twelve months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination, totaling Kshs. 4,192,656.
Issuance of a certificate of service.
Coverage of costs related to the suit.
Evidence and Testimonies
Claimant’s Testimony: During the hearing, Moses Opiyo, as CW1, adopted his witness statement as evidence and presented various documents, including his letter of appointment, suspension, and termination notices, and minutes from management meetings.
Response to Allegations: In his statement, Opiyo detailed his response to the show cause letter he received, which cited thirteen allegations against him. He argued that he had not been provided with the investigation report that formed the basis of these allegations.
Conflict of Interest: Opiyo highlighted that the sole reason for his dismissal was his association with Schaltmax Enterprises, owned by his wife, which he had disclosed before his suspension. He emphasized that the company had been regularly pre-qualified as a supplier through proper channels, without his undue influence.
Role in Procurement: Opiyo attested that he did not have unilateral authority in supplier selection and that decisions were made collectively at the management level. He also pointed out that the Finance Office was aware of the supplier’s relationship with him and had raised no concerns.
Lack of Evidence: The Claimant asserted that allegations regarding substandard products and unjustifiable supplier changes were unsupported by independent reports or audits. Additionally, there was no documentation provided to him on procurement policies that he allegedly violated.
Supporting Witness: Ms. Angela Mwikali Kyalo corroborated Opiyo’s testimony, noting that Schaltmax Enterprises was a pre-existing supplier and that no formal procurement policy was communicated during her tenure. She also revealed pressure from management to sign statements against Opiyo.
Key Issues for Determination
Procedural and Substantive Fairness: The court must assess whether the dismissal process adhered to fairness standards, examining the clarity of procurement roles, the alleged conflict of interest, and the provision of policies to the Claimant.
Employer’s Belief and Evidence: The court needs to determine if the employer held a genuine belief in the reasons for dismissal based on undisclosed investigation reports and absent witnesses.
Rights of Appeal: The validity of the right to appeal offered to the Claimant must be scrutinized to ensure it was meaningful and not merely procedural.
This judgment will consider these aspects comprehensively to deliver a fair and just decision in line with the requirements of the court.
The Respondent's Case
Overview
The Respondent's case centers on the employment termination of the Claimant, who served as a senior employee from March 2013 to October 2022. The Respondent asserts that the termination was conducted lawfully, adhering to constitutional, natural justice, and labor law principles. The Respondent claims the dismissal was carried out for valid reasons, communicated clearly, and preceded by a fair disciplinary hearing on October 11, 2022.
Key Details of the Termination
The Respondent contends that the Claimant, in his role as Human Resource Manager, was obligated to maintain good faith, integrity, and compliance with company policies. It is claimed that the Claimant failed to meet these expectations, leading to his dismissal. The Respondent maintains that the Claimant was paid all terminal dues and received a certificate of service, thus, the claim should be dismissed with costs.
Witness Testimony
Testimony of Mr. Joseph Kithikwa (RW1)
The Respondent's sole witness, Mr. Joseph Kithikwa, the Group Head of Human Resource, provided evidence supporting the Respondent's position. He presented several documents as exhibits, including:
The Claimant’s letter of appointment
The Staff Handbook
Correspondence related to the disciplinary process
The letter of summary dismissal
The Claimant's final payslip and bank transfer advice
The certificate of service
Disclosure and Investigation
RW1 highlighted a key incident where the Claimant disclosed his association with Schaltmax Enterprises, a supplier, through a Declaration of Interest Form. This disclosure led to an investigation revealing that Schaltmax Enterprises, owned by the Claimant’s wife, had been supplying the Respondent for six years without proper disclosure, indicating a conflict of interest.
Findings of Misconduct
The investigation uncovered several issues:
Instances of the Claimant advocating for payments to Schaltmax Enterprises.
Replacement of other suppliers with Schaltmax Enterprises without competitive bidding.
Procurement actions not originating from user departments.
False claims about the availability of goods from other suppliers.
Disciplinary Process
The disciplinary process included:
A suspension letter dated September 21, 2022
A show cause letter dated October 3, 2022
The Claimant's response dated October 5, 2022
A notice and disciplinary hearing held on October 11, 2022
Despite the Claimant being heard during the disciplinary hearing and waiving his right to representation, the Respondent concluded that the Claimant’s defense did not counter the serious allegations, amounting to gross misconduct. The Claimant was summarily dismissed on October 18, 2022, with an option to appeal, which he did not pursue within the stipulated timeframe.
Cross-Examination Revelations
During cross-examination, RW1 made several concessions:
No investigation report was issued to the Claimant or filed in court.
No witnesses were brought before the disciplinary panel to confront the Claimant.
The Respondent lacked a formal procurement policy.
The Respondent never complained about the quality of goods from Schaltmax Enterprises nor returned any goods.
These admissions could significantly impact the assessment of the procedural fairness of the Claimant’s termination. The Respondent maintains that the termination was both substantively and procedurally fair, despite these concessions.

0 Comments