Charleston Travel Ltd’s management has suffered a significant setback after the Employment and Labour Relations Court dismissed its application against former employees Sophia Njeri Wanyoike, Miriam Mugane, Denis Gachanja Kiai, and Patrick Karani Wanjohi. The management alleged that the former employees had engaged in fraud, conspiracy to defraud, misappropriation of funds, and unjust enrichment, and sought to recover a liquidated sum of Sh18,831,486. It also sought remedies including recovery of the alleged financial loss, freezing of bank accounts, attachment before judgment, tracing of funds, and the rendition of accounts. These remedies are ancillary to a civil claim based on alleged fraud and financial impropriety. The former employees are now free of the application’s claims.
Ruling Summary: Employment & Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case Overview
The case involves Charleston Travel Ltd as the Claimant/Applicant, and the Respondents: Sophia Njeri Wanyoike, Miriam Mugane, Denis Gachanja Kiai, and Patrick Karani Wanjohi. The primary matter for determination is the Respondents' Notices of Preliminary Objection seeking to strike out the Claimant’s suit on jurisdictional grounds.
Grounds for Preliminary Objection
Jurisdictional Challenge: The Respondents argue that the Employment and Labour Relations Court (ELRC) lacks jurisdiction under Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, and Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. They claim that the issues presented are civil in nature, involving allegations of fraud and financial misappropriation, which should be heard by the High Court.
Nature of the Dispute: The Respondents assert that their dismissal occurred before the proceedings, negating any employer-employee relationship necessary to confer jurisdiction to the ELRC.
Monetary Claims: They argue the reliefs sought, such as recovery of funds, freezing of accounts, and tracing of funds, are ancillary to civil claims rather than employment disputes.
Salary Consideration: The 2nd Respondent adds that the case should be addressed in the Magistrate's Court due to her salary level, suggesting a commercial rather than an employment dispute.
Claimant's Arguments
The Claimant counters that:
Intertwined Allegations: The claims against the Respondents are interconnected with allegations of conspiracy, justifying the jurisdiction of the ELRC.
Employment Context: The alleged misconduct occurred during the Respondents’ employment, involving breaches of contractual and statutory duties, thus falling within the ELRC’s jurisdiction.
Financial and Property Claims: The Claimant maintains that the financial losses and property issues arose from the employment relationship.
Jurisdiction of ELRC: Under Section 86 of the Employment Act, they argue the ELRC can adjudicate disputes arising from contracts of service, including those with former employees.
Court's Determination
The court evaluated whether it has jurisdiction based on the substance of the claim:
Substance Over Form: The court emphasized examining the essence of the claim rather than labels. The suit’s principal nature, involving alleged fraud and financial recovery, classifies it as a civil claim.
Precedents: The court referenced similar cases where financial impropriety claims were deemed civil rather than employment disputes.
Employment vs. Civil Claims: The employment relationship, while part of the background, is not the crux of the legal issue, which is substantially a civil claim.
Jurisdictional Conclusion: The court concludes the ELRC lacks jurisdiction, as the primary matter is related to financial impropriety rather than employment obligations.
Final Ruling
The court upheld the Preliminary Objections from the 1st and 2nd Respondents, striking out the Claimant’s suit with costs awarded to the Respondents. The Claimant is advised to pursue the matter in an appropriate civil court. The ruling also applies to a related case, ELRCC E425 of 2026, involving similar facts.
Judge C. N. Baari delivered the ruling on November 5, 2026.
Appearances
Mr. Githumbi for the Claimant/Applicant
Ms. Mati for the 1st Respondent
Mr. Mbogori for the 2nd Respondent
Mr. Wanyangu holding brief for Mr. Namada for the 3rd & 4th Respondents

0 Comments