Principal Michael Ngalu Mutie (left) with Motivational Speaker Sam
Barely a year after his controversial transfer from Mwingi Boys to St. Matthias Mulumba Matinyani Boys School in Kitui County, pressure is mounting on the Teachers Service Commission to transfer the school’s chief principal, Mr. Michael Ngalu Mutie.
Stakeholders, parents, members of the Board of Management (BoM), and members of the Parents Association (PA) have reportedly agreed that Mr. Mutie should leave by the end of this term at the latest. They are calling for the school to open for the first term of 2026 under a new principal. They accuse him of high-handedness, intimidation, coercion, and threatening people who hold differing opinions. A PA member who spoke to us on condition of anonymity, citing fears of victimization, alleged that Mr. Mutie runs the school as though it were his personal property and makes decisions without consultation. The member further claimed that he coerces and intimidates PA members into approving allegedly illegal levies that directly benefit him. Teachers are also said to be demoralized, with concerns that he has introduced outdated teaching and academic programmes that will not improve the school’s performance. He is also said to invite motivational speaker Sam Vidambu to address candidates rather than invest in teachers to provide extra lessons and better support students. A teacher who spoke to us on condition of anonymity alleged that Mr. Mutie had asked parents to contribute Sh3,000 each for “passing exams.” The teacher claimed this meant the money would be used to bribe examination invigilators and officials to allow students to engage in examination irregularities. Former colleagues at Mwingi High School have reportedly described him as a shrewd principal who knows how to manipulate and bribe examination invigilators and officials to enable students to cheat. They allege this was why Mwingi Boys performed well in the KCSE examinations.St. Mattthias Mulumba Matinyani Boys School for the Year Ended 30 June 2025 Kitui
Unsupported Cash and Cash Equivalents
The financial statements reveal a cash and cash equivalents balance of Kshs.8,803,233. This includes Kshs.8,794,881 as cash at bank and Kshs.8,352 as cash in hand. However, the cash in hand lacks verification through a Board of Survey report. Additionally, although the School manages seven bank accounts, bank reconciliation statements and bank confirmation certificates for the Constituency Development Fund (CDF) Project Account were not provided, rendering the accuracy and completeness of these figures unverifiable.
Unauthorized Expenditure
The budgeted versus actual amounts show a final receipts budget of Kshs.84,060,381 compared to actual receipts of Kshs.79,349,745, indicating under-funding by Kshs.4,710,636. The School's expenditure of Kshs.92,988,829 surpassed the actual receipts, resulting in an over-utilization of Kshs.13,639,084. This exceeded the budgeted expenditure by Kshs.2,600,095, which is unauthorized. Moreover, there were no explanatory notes for deviations of 10% or more in the budget statements, and some items were not initially budgeted.
Late Transfer of Infrastructure Funds
Operations grants amounting to Kshs.10,971,698 included infrastructure grants of Kshs.6,107,950, which were not timely transferred to the Infrastructure Bank Account as required by the Ministry of Education's directive. The delay beyond the 15-day period constitutes a breach of law.
Irregular Transfer of Funds to KESSHA
An amount of Kshs.98,500 was irregularly transferred to Kenya Secondary School Heads Association (KESSHA), a welfare organization for school principals, from the operations payments of Kshs.11,406,370.
Failure to Develop and Implement a School Improvement Plan
The School did not have an approved School Improvement Plan, violating the Ministry of Education's requirement for a three-year planning cycle focusing on key educational areas.
Non-Deduction and Remittance of Capacity Building Levy
The School failed to deduct and remit the Public Procurement Capacity Building Levy of 0.03% on procurement contracts, contrary to the Levy Order, 2023 and Legal Notice No. 206 of 2024.
Governance and Oversight Issues
Lack of an Audit Committee
The absence of an Audit Committee contravenes Section 61(2) of the Basic Education Act, 2013, leaving management operations without internal oversight.
Lack of Human Resource Policy
The School lacks an approved Human Resource Policy, with no documented procedures for recruitment, promotion, and staff welfare, among others. Furthermore, the absence of a qualified nurse for student health services is noted.
Lack of a Functional Procurement Unit
The School did not establish a procurement unit managed by qualified professionals, as required by the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015. This oversight led to inadequately managed procurement activities.
Incomplete Fixed Assets Register
The fixed assets register inaccurately reflects disposals as depreciation and shows a land donation with nil historical cost balance. Only a portion of the land has ownership documentation.
Long Outstanding Accounts Receivables
The accounts receivables balance includes fees arrears of Kshs.20,083,685, which have been outstanding for over three years, casting doubt on their recoverability.
Conclusion
The audit, conducted in line with ISSAI 2315 and ISSAI 2330 standards, found significant issues in the School's financial and operational management, indicating ineffective internal controls, risk management, and governance systems.


0 Comments