RAY STORES CEO AMRISHBAI PATEL ACUSSED OF PROTECTING TOP MANAGERS DEMANDING SEX FAVOURS FROM MARRIED EMPLOYEES,

Reports of companies hiring staff without formally signing employment contracts have become increasingly common in Kenya, as employers take advantage of the shortage of jobs.

One such company is Ray Stores Limited, a Kenyan business operating mainly as a general merchant, food and beverage wholesaler, and retail shop. Staff allege that the company’s management relies on heavy-handed conduct, coercion, threats, and intimidation. Investigations reportedly indicate that the company hires employees on a temporary basis without contracts and dismisses them at will, sometimes on seemingly flimsy grounds. One reported case involves Anderson Ifedha, who was allegedly dismissed without due procedure by the company’s Managing Director and CEO, Amrishbai Patel. Employees allege that senior management hires casual workers, pays them poorly, and provides no employment contracts. They also claim that some managers demand sexual favors from female employees and retaliate against those who refuse by victimizing them, making false allegations, setting traps, and ultimately dismissing them without compensation. The managers, who are described as Indian, are also accused of seeking extramarital relationships with married female employees. Staff further allege that racial abuse is prevalent at the company. The Managing Director and CEO, Amrishbai Patel, is alleged to have boasted that he is untouchable because he is friends with COTU leader Francis Atwoli and Homa Bay Governor Gladys Wanga. He reportedly claims to provide campaign funds to Wanga and to pay Atwoli a monthly fee for protection. It has also been alleged that statutory deductions, including NSSF, PAYE, SHA, and the Housing Levy, are taken from employees who have contracts but are not remitted. These claims raise concerns about possible tax and statutory-compliance violations and warrant investigation. KRA should consider conducting a thorough inquiry.

Judgment Analysis

Introduction

This case involves an appeal from the Employment and Labour Relations Court of Kenya at Kisumu, concerning alleged unlawful termination of employment. The Appellant, Anderson Ifedha, brought the suit against Ray Stores Limited and its CEO/Managing Director. The appeal arises from a judgment delivered by Hon. L.D Ogombe in the Kisumu CMCELRC No. E231 of 2023.


Background of the Case

Appellant's Claims

The Appellant, Anderson Ifedha, initiated the suit with a Memorandum of Claim dated 5th October 2023. He alleged unlawful termination of his employment, seeking payment of terminal dues, a certificate of service, and any other relief deemed fit by the court. 


Anderson claimed he was employed as a turn boy and salesperson by the Respondents in 2014 at a daily wage rate, which translated to a monthly salary of Kshs. 11,700/-. He asserted that his employment was terminated abruptly on 28th September 2023 when he sought clarification on a new employment contract introduced by an unidentified contractor.


Respondents' Defense

Ray Stores Limited, the 1st Respondent, acknowledged the Appellant's employment beginning in 2014 but contended that his employment was on a contractual basis. They argued that the Appellant deserted his duties following a chaotic incident at the workplace, during which another employee was injured, and the police became involved.


Consolidation of Cases

On 27th November 2023, the Appellant’s case was consolidated with sixteen other similar cases. The consolidation was due to the shared nature of the claims and the involvement of the same legal representatives for each party. Kisumu CMELRC No. E223 of 2023 was designated as the lead file.


Hearing and Evidence

Appellant's Evidence

The Appellant's statement was adopted as evidence. He presented various documents, including staff identification cards, a text message inviting him for clearance and payment, and an Mpesa statement.


Respondents' Evidence

Two witnesses were called by the Respondents:

  1. RW1: Duncan Alila Adipo

    • An Administration Manager at Retention Management Services.

    • He testified that the 1st Respondent engaged Retention Management Services after the previous contractor's contract expired.

    • He claimed that the workers, including the Appellant, refused to sign new contracts and resorted to violence, leading to the police being involved.

    • Documents produced included an outsourcing contract, police reports, and payroll records.

  2. RW2: Amrish Patel

    • A director of the 1st Respondent.

    • He reiterated the transition to Retention Management Services and stated that the Appellant and other workers resisted signing new contracts.

    • He maintained that the workers deserted duty after the incident was reported to the police.

Conclusion

This case highlights the complexities involved in employment transitions and contractual agreements. The court's decision will need to consider the legality and fairness of the termination, the validity of the new contract proposals, and the alleged conduct of both the Appellant and the Respondents during the transition period. The outcome will hinge on the evidence presented and the legal frameworks governing employment relations in Kenya.

Post a Comment

0 Comments