Tensions at Chelilis Girls as former principal Mary Cheplilan and current principal Irine Munai trade accusations over Auditor-General report


 It has been exactly one year since Madam Mary Cheplilan handed over leadership of Chelilis Girls to Madam Irine Munai, the school’s new principal. Cheplilan previously served as principal of Kaboson Girls. Serious concerns have emerged following an Auditor-General’s report alleging significant mismanagement at Chelilis Girls during Cheplilan’s leadership.

Madam Munai, the current principal, has reportedly stated that the audit report covers the period when Cheplilan was in charge, not her own tenure. She has said that any audit queries should be directed to Cheplilan, who was responsible for the school at the time. Munai claims she inherited a school with millions of shillings in unpaid bills, which Cheplilan had not settled. She also said she took over a school with outstanding arrears of Sh24 million, which had accumulated over the previous two years. However, a Parents Association (PA) member who spoke to us on condition of anonymity said Munai should also be held accountable for the report, arguing that many of the audit queries concern her tenure in 2025.

At St. Theresa’s Tartar, Madam Mary is facing serious challenges, as stakeholders claim she has not lived up to the standards set by her predecessor. They accuse her of arrogance, coercion, intimidation, and threatening those who express opposing views. Over the past year, she has reportedly accumulated pending bills amounting to Sh10 million. Allegedly, she pays only contractors and suppliers who agree to provide her with kickbacks. She is also said to have fallen out with members of the Board of Management (BoM) because she does not implement the board’s resolutions and is accused of showing them little respect. Students and teachers at St. Theresa’s claim that discipline has declined since she took office. Grade Ten students reportedly left school cursing her, amid several alleged cases of lesbianism and same-sex relationships. They say older students forced, coerced, and pressured them into same-sex relationships and sexually molested them. According to the students, she has not acted on these complaints, leading some girls to believe that she secretly supports LGBTQ activities, which they describe as illegal. She is also accused of having an extramarital affair with a board member whose name has been withheld. They are reportedly said to have been seen socializing at high-end hotels, where they dine and spend the night.

Report of the Auditor-General on Chelilis Girls Secondary School for the Year Ended 30 June 2025 Kericho County


Unsupported School Fund Income – Parents’ Contributions

The statement of financial performance and Note 4 to the financial statements report school fund income from parents’ contributions of Kshs.32,923,454 in respect of fees paid by students. However, this amount was not supported by individual student statements or a comprehensive fee register showing details such as students’ names, admission numbers, and fees paid. Further, an analysis of the approved fee structure and student population recorded in the student registers for the year under review indicates that expected school fees totalled Kshs.30,177,200, resulting in an unexplained variance of Kshs.2,746,254. 

The reported amount also includes bursaries and scholarships awarded by various entities, including the Constituency Development Fund (CDF), County Governments, National Government agencies, and private institutions. However, the School does not maintain records of bursaries and scholarships received from each source. 

The School did not provide for audit review a detailed list of beneficiaries, including their names, admission numbers, and amounts awarded; official receipts; bank deposit slips evidencing receipt of funds; or schedules confirming that the funds were credited to beneficiaries’ fee accounts. In the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of the school fund income from parents’ contributions, amounting to Kshs.32,923,454, could not be confirmed.  

Unsupported Payments for Boarding and School Fund The statement of financial performance and Note 9 to the financial statements report boarding and school fund payments of Kshs.29,205,904. This amount includes expenditure totalling Kshs.8,173,427 that was not supported by requisitions from user departments, local purchase orders or local service orders, quotations, evaluation minutes, professional opinions, inspection and acceptance reports, goods received notes, contract agreements, or interim or completion certificates.

Unsupported Cash and Cash Equivalents Balance 

The statement of assets and liabilities reports a cash and cash equivalents balance of Kshs.2,572,453. The balance includes five (5) bank accounts with balances of Kshs.466,702, Kshs.33,379, Kshs.91,925, Kshs.96,925 and Kshs.1,884,130, as disclosed in Note 10 to the financial statements. However, the bank balances were not supported by bank reconciliation statements. Consequently, the accuracy and completeness of the bank balances, totalling Kshs.2,572,453, could not be confirmed. 


Unconfirmed Student Enrolment Data 

The statement of financial performance reports tuition capitation grants totalling Kshs.2,001,360. However, a comparison of data in the National Education Management and Information System (NEMIS) with records held by the County Director of Education showed that, during the 2024/2025 financial year, NEMIS recorded two thousand two hundred and thirteen (2,213) students, while the County Director of Education’s records showed two thousand two hundred and eighty-four (2,284) students. 


This discrepancy resulted in the School being underfunded by Kshs.312,681. The difference was contrary to Ministry of Education Circular MOE.HQS/3/13/3 dated 16 June 2021, on implementation of Free Day Secondary Education (FDSE), which requires all learners to be registered in NEMIS and principals to ensure that student records are accurate. Consequently, the School’s underfunding may have affected service delivery to students.  


Irregular Banking of Government Grants for Operations 

The statement of financial performance, as disclosed in Note 2 to the financial statements, reports operational capitation grants of Kshs.8,718,641. However, a review of the operations bank account statements revealed that Government capitation grants and school fund income collected from parents were deposited into the same bank account. This was contrary to Ministry of Education Circular Ref. No. MOE.MOE/CONF/GS) dated 26 November 2019, which requires Government subsidies for op


Failure to Prepare a School Improvement Plan During the year under review, the School did not have an approved School Improvement Plan. This was contrary to Section 2.2 of the Ministry of Education Operation Manual for Utilization of Learner Capitation Grant and Other School Funds. 

The Manual requires schools, during each three-year school improvement planning cycle, to identify one priority area in each of four key areas for implementation: curriculum implementation; foundational literacy and numeracy outcomes; an enabling learning environment; and parental involvement and community engagement. Under the circumstances, Management was in breach of the Ministry of Education guidelines.  

Non-Compliance with Ethnic Diversity Requirements A review of payroll records revealed that all twenty-four (24) School staff members belonged to the same ethnic community. This contravenes Section 7(2) of the National Cohesion and Integration Act, 2008, which provides that no more than one-third of employees should come from any one ethnic community. Under the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.  

Long Outstanding Receivables 
The statement of assets and liabilities reports accounts receivable of Kshs.24,327,218 in fee arrears, as disclosed in Note 13 to the financial statements. This amount includes Kshs.19,185,545 that had been outstanding for more than one (1) year. 

However, no ageing analysis or policy for impairing long-outstanding fee arrears was available, raising doubt about whether the full accounts receivable balance will be recovered. 

Accordingly, the existence of effective debt management mechanisms could not be confirmed. 

Lack of a Functional Procurement Unit 
The School had not established a procurement function led by a qualified procurement professional, contrary to Section 47(2) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015. Instead, procurement activities were carried out by officers without the required procurement qualifications. 

Lack of Internal Audit Function 
During the year under review, the School had not established an internal audit unit, as required by Regulation 166 (1) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015. The regulation requires the internal audit unit of a National Government entity to assess the School’s effectiveness through an internal performance appraisal and comment on that effectiveness in the annual report to the National Treasury. 

Accordingly, the existence of effective oversight mechanisms could not be confirmed. 4. Lack of Risk Management Policy A review of documents and records revealed that Management had not established a Risk Management Policy. 

This was contrary to Regulation 165 (1) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015, which requires the Accounting Officer to ensure that a national government entity develops risk management strategies, including a fraud prevention mechanism; and a


Unsupported School Fund Income - Parents' Contributions

The financial statements show a school fund income of Kshs.32,923,454 attributed to parents' contributions. However, this amount lacks the necessary supporting documentation, such as individual student statements or a comprehensive fee register with details including student names, admission numbers, and fees paid. 


There is a notable discrepancy of Kshs.2,746,254 between the expected and reported fees, which remains unexplained. Additionally, bursaries and scholarships are not adequately recorded, preventing the confirmation of the accuracy and completeness of the income balance.


Unsupported Payments for Boarding and School Fund

The financial statements disclose payments of Kshs.29,205,904 for boarding and school funds. An expenditure of Kshs.8,173,427 lacks support through proper documentation like requisitions, purchase orders, quotations, and related records, making it impossible to confirm the accuracy and propriety of these payments.


Unsupported Cash and Cash Equivalents Balance

The assets and liabilities statement reflects a cash and cash equivalents balance of Kshs.2,572,453 across five bank accounts. However, these balances lack supporting bank reconciliation statements, making it difficult to confirm their accuracy and completeness.


Unconfirmed Student Enrolment Data

There is a discrepancy in student enrolment data between the National Education Management Information System (NEMIS) and the County Director of Education's records, showing an underfunding of Kshs.312,681 due to inaccurate records. This underfunding may affect service delivery to the students.


Irregular Banking of Government Grants for Operations

The school has not adhered to Ministry of Education guidelines regarding the banking of government capitation grants, which were mixed with school fund income in the operations account. This contravenes the Ministry's directives.


Failure to Deduct Capacity Building Levy

The school failed to deduct a 0.03% capacity building levy from procurement payments, violating the Levy Order 2023 by the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority.


Late Transfer of Infrastructure Funds

Infrastructure grants were not transferred to the designated account within the prescribed 15 days, breaching Ministry of Education guidelines.


Failure to Prepare School Improvement Plan

The school lacks a formal School Improvement Plan, which is a requirement for effective planning and resource allocation in key areas of development.


Non-Compliance with Ethnic Diversity Requirements

The school's staff lacks ethnic diversity, with all 24 employees from a single community, violating the National Cohesion and Integration Act, 2008.


Non-Compliance with 30% Procurement Reservation

The school has not complied with the requirement to reserve 30% of procurement for enterprises owned by women, youth, persons with disabilities, and other disadvantaged groups.


Lack of Information Technology Controls

The school lacks IT control measures, including an ICT policy, disaster recovery plan, and information security policy, putting essential data at risk.

These findings highlight critical areas where Chelilis Girls Secondary School must improve to ensure compliance with regulations and enhance its financial and operational management. Immediate action is necessary to address these issues and safeguard the school's interests and the welfare of its students and staff.

Post a Comment

0 Comments