M.P. Shah Chania High School Gitau James caught pants down!!!!

 



M.P. Shah Chania High School: Governance Under Scrutiny


Principal Gitau James Faces Audit Queries

The principal of M.P. Shah Chania High School, Gitau James, is poised to face the parliamentary committee on Public Investment and Education due to pressing audit queries. The auditor general's report for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2025, has unearthed concerning issues of financial mismanagement, corruption, and serious administrative failures within the institution.


Stakeholder Concerns Over Infrastructure and Academic Progression

Since assuming his role in March 2025, Principal Gitau James has faced criticism from various stakeholders, including parents, the Board of Management (BoG), and the Parents Association (PA). 


They argue that he has failed to advance the school's infrastructure or academic achievements. The absence of any substantial projects under his leadership has raised alarm, leading to mounting dissatisfaction among the school community.


Pressure on Teachers Service Commission (TSC)

The Teachers Service Commission (TSC) is currently under intense pressure from stakeholders to reassign Principal Gitau by the end of the current term. Failure to do so might result in a physical eviction by January 2027, as threatened by the concerned parties. Stakeholders have already identified a preferred successor, someone who is considered a local and more attuned to the community’s needs.


Allegations of Intimidation and Financial Misconduct

Principal Gitau is accused of employing highhandedness, intimidation, and coercion tactics. There are allegations of him imposing illegal levies that purportedly benefit him personally, contributing to the school's substantial unpaid bills. These bills are reportedly settled only when contractors agree to provide kickbacks, further highlighting financial irregularities.


Decline in School Discipline

The school's discipline has reportedly deteriorated, with allegations of sexual molestation and harassment that have not been addressed adequately. Students allege that Principal Gitau refrains from taking necessary actions against such incidents due to his involvement in an extramarital affair with a married teacher at the school.


The unfolding situation at M.P. Shah Chania High School underscores the urgent need for intervention and transparency to restore trust and integrity within the institution. Stakeholders are hopeful that the upcoming parliamentary committee review will bring about much-needed accountability and change.


Auditor-General's Report on M.P. Shah Chania High School


Unapproved Fees for Parents Association Support Programme

The financial examination of M.P. Shah Chania High School for the year ending June 30, 2025, highlights several areas of concern. One of the significant issues is the unapproved fees collected under the Parents Association Support Programme. The financial statements show that the school fund income, largely from parents' contributions, totaled Kshs. 118,025,205. Within this amount, a sum of Kshs. 1,444,525 was attributed to the Parents Association Support Programme.


However, it was found that the school charged Kshs. 6,500 per student for this programme without obtaining the necessary approval from the Ministry of Education, as mandated by the County Education Board. This action contravenes Government Circular No. MOE.HQS/3/13/3 dated June 16, 2021, which outlines that parents are only responsible for paying for school uniforms, boarding-related costs, and lunch for day scholars. Thus, the school's management was in breach of the law.


Lack of Functional Procurement Unit

Another concern identified is the absence of a functional procurement unit within the school. According to Section 47(2) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015, and Regulation 33 of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Regulations, 2020, the school should have an established procurement function managed by qualified professionals. Instead, procurement activities were conducted by individuals without the requisite qualifications, and none of the procurement activities had the necessary professional opinion as required by Section 84(1) of the Act. This represents a further legal breach by the school's management.


Under-funding of Capitation Grants

The report also points to the under-funding of capitation grants. The financial statements and associated notes reveal government grants allocated for tuition, operations, and infrastructure amounted to Kshs. 4,182,461, Kshs. 12,528,478, respectively. However, the funding appears inadequate relative to the needs and expectations set forth by the governmental framework. This under-funding has likely impacted the school's ability to maintain and improve its educational infrastructure and services.


Failure to Deduct and Remit Public Procurement Capacity Building Levy

Lastly, the financial review uncovered a failure to deduct and remit the Public Procurement Capacity Building Levy. The financial performance statement and notes highlight a total expenditure of Kshs. 125,318,267 on goods and services. Within this, Kshs. 14,125,554 was allocated to procurement contracts with various suppliers. However, the school did not deduct the required 0.03% levy on these contracts, as stipulated by the Levy Order, 2023 from the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority. This oversight constitutes another breach of the law by the school's management.

In summary, the report indicates significant compliance issues within M.P. Shah Chania High School's financial and operational practices, necessitating immediate corrective action to align with legal and regulatory requirements.


Lack of Internal Audit Review

During the year under review, M.P. Shah Chania High School did not have an internal audit unit. This absence is contrary to Regulation 166(1) and (2) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015. These regulations mandate that a National Government entity must have an internal audit unit to evaluate its effectiveness through an internal performance appraisal. The results of this appraisal should be included in the annual report submitted to The National Treasury.

As a result, the School did not benefit from the oversight and advisory roles typically provided by an internal audit function.


Lack of Adequate Facilities in the Institution

An assessment of the School's infrastructure capacity highlighted significant inadequacies in key facilities necessary to support the student body and staff for the period ending 30 June 2025. The following table outlines the discrepancies between required and actual available facilities:

FacilityQuantity RequiredActual Quantity AvailableGap

Classrooms

34

12

22

Dining Hall

For 1,637 students

For 1,000 students

637

Library

For 1,500 students

For 1,000 students

500

Dormitories

20

19

1

Computer Laboratory

6

3

3

Electricity Laboratory

3

1

2

Home Science Lab

1

0

1

E-Laboratory

Required

Not available

All

These shortfalls indicate a pressing need for development and expansion to adequately meet the needs of the School community.


Lack of Asset Ownership Documents

Annex 2 to the financial statements shows a fixed assets register balance of Kshs.213,759,960. However, the School occupies land of undetermined value which is not included in the School’s assets. On 25 September 2025, the School applied for a lease from Thika Municipality for the land it occupies. As of the audit date, the School had not obtained any ownership documents for this parcel of land.


This lack of documentation raises concerns about the effectiveness of asset management measures, as the existence and legal ownership of the land cannot be confirmed.


Conclusion

The audit was conducted according to the standards ISSAI 2315 and ISSAI 2330, which require planning and execution to ensure effective internal control, risk management, and governance processes are in place. Based on the evidence obtained, it appears that significant improvements are needed in these areas for M.P. Shah Chania High School.

Post a Comment

0 Comments