The High Court has heard that a disputed Karen property associated with former Cabinet Secretary Raphael Tuju had already been sold and transferred before any injunctive orders were issued, as parties clashed over an application for stay pending appeal.
During proceedings before Justice Moses Ado, Ultra Eureka Limited told the court it lawfully acquired the property through a public auction conducted on October 1, 2024. The company said the sale was undertaken under the statutory power of sale by Knight Frank Valuers Limited.
“The property was sold in a public auction and transferred. When interim orders were vacated, we took possession. There is nothing to stay because the property is no longer in the hands of the plaintiffs,” counsel for Ultra Eureka submitted.
The firm argued that interim orders halting the transaction were issued only on October 28, 2024, weeks after the auction and the initiation of transfer processes. It maintained that the property is now registered in its name and fully out of the plaintiffs’ control.
The submissions were in response to an application by Tuju and Dari Limited seeking to suspend the execution of a March 9 ruling delivered by Justice Josephine Mongare. In that decision, the court struck out their amended plaint and lifted earlier orders barring dealings with the property.
Ultra Eureka further argued that even if the court finds fault in the transaction, damages - not recovery of the property - would be the appropriate remedy.
Opposing the application, Knight Frank Valuers Limited described the request for stay as defective and legally untenable, arguing that the ruling in question amounted to a negative order incapable of being stayed.
The East African Development Bank also urged the court to dismiss the application, insisting that the plaintiffs had not demonstrated any substantial loss and that the outstanding debt should be recovered through the pledged security.
“Facts have not changed. The debts remain unpaid, and the plaintiffs have not shown they will suffer substantial loss. The pledged securities should be allowed to be recovered,” its lawyer submitted.
However, lawyer Paul Nyamodi, representing Tuju and Dari Limited, argued that the property is unique and its loss would cause irreparable harm if the appeal succeeds.
“Each property is unique, and if disposed of, and the plaintiff succeeds on appeal, he may not be able to recover it as it may go beyond the jurisdiction of the court,” Nyamodi told the court.

0 Comments